Hurricane Movement, Forecasting, and Dangers

Hurricane Occurence, Movement

Figure 3:In an average year, 90 - 100 tropical storms develop. This figure shows where they form and the most common paths they take.

Figure 4: Sea surface temperature map for the northern hemisphere summer. The yellow, orange, and red colors show water temperatures warm enough to sustain hurricanes (> 26.5°C).

Hurricanes derive their energy from the warm tropical water and from the latent heat released as water vapor condenses into clouds.

Figure 3 shows where most hurricanes are born and the general direction in which they move. Notice that they form over most of the tropical ocean basins, except in the tropical South Atlantic and in the tropical eastern South Pacific, which are the tropical ocean basins on either side of South America. The ocean surface temperatures in these areas are too cold throughout the year for tropical storm development (see figure 4). The warm waters of the Western North Pacific is the world's hot spot for tropical storm development. Click on the link to view a Global map showing the tracks of all tropical cyclones from 1985 to 2005. The figure clearly shows the western Pacific hot spot, the lack of storms near South America, and the vulnerability of the entire US Atlantic and Gulf coast to hurricane strikes.

The table below give statistics for an "average" season in each ocean basin. The numbers in the table are slightly different from the numbers in figure 3. This is because figure 3 is based on an averaging period of 1900 to 2000, while the numbers in the table are based on an averaging period of 1950 to 2000.

Tropical storms and hurricanes most commonly move from east toward west, especially early in their lifecycles. There is a tendency for these storms to curve away from the equator toward the end of their lifecycles. This is true for both Northern and Southern Hemisphere storms. However, as discussed below, a given hurricane can move in any direction.

Movement and Seasonal Timing of Atlantic Hurricanes

It is shown above that the official Atlantic Hurricane season lasts from June first through the end of November, and that on average, there are 10.6 tropical storms, 5.9 hurricanes, and 2.0 major hurricanes (category 3 and higher). Figure 8 shows that Atlantic hurricane activity peaks in early September and that storms occasionally form outside the official hurricane season in May and December. This pattern of hurricane occurrence is closely correlated with the seasonal change in Atlantic sea surface temperature. The highest sea surface temperatures in the Atlantic typically occur in early September.

Figure 8: Average number of Atlantic Hurricanes per century as a function of calendar date.

The most important determinent of hurricane movement is the local environmental air flow in the middle troposphere. In other words, hurricanes tend to be "steered" around by the winds blowing at about 500 mb pressure (5 to 6 km above sea level). In late summer and early fall the "typical" wind patterns at 500 mb are generally easterly (or east toward west) below or south of 30° North latitude and westerly (west toward east) above or north of 30° North latitude. The reason for this is that a broad and elongated area of higher pressure is typically found near 30° latitude (See Figure N (top)). The figure shows that on average there are zones of higher pressure near 30° latitude in both the northern and southern hemisphere, which result in east to west 500 mb steering level winds throughout the tropics in both hemispheres. These semi-permanent belts of high pressure near 30° latitude are called subtropical highs. These "steering level" winds blow parallel to the pressure contours because they are upper level winds, not surface winds. The reason why the winds south of the equator are also east toward west is that the Coriolis force turns the winds 90° to the left of the pressure gradient force in the Southern Hemisphere, while in the Northern Hemisphere the Coriolis force turns the wind 90° to the right of the pressure gradient force. Differences between the northern and southern hemisphere will not be emphasized in this course. You should be famailar with what happens in the Northern Hemisphere.

Northern Hemisphere hurricanes that are below or south of 30° latitude will generally be steered from east to west. However, as shown in figure 3 above, it is not uncommon for hurricanes turn away from the equator (toward the north in the Northern Hemisphere and toward the south in the Southern Hemisphere) at some point along their track. If hurricanes move north of 30° latitude, they often make a turn toward the east or begin moving from west toward east. This is because the steering level winds north of 30° latitude are typically west toward east.

Figure 5: Burmuda high and hurricane tracks.

The subtropical high pressure area over the Atlantic ocean is often found as a high pressure cell (See Figure N (bottom)). While the position and overall size of this feature changes, its center is often located near the island of Burmuda, hence it is often called the Burmuda High. This is quite important to hurricane movement in the vicinity of the United States as shown in figure 5. In the top panel, tropical cylones moving across the Atlantic will turn northward before reaching Florida, while in the bottom panel, they are steered toward the east coast of Florida. In situations where the Burmuda high extends slightly further west, tropical systems can be steered toward the west either across Florida or south of Florida before turning north to hit the United States coastline along the Gulf of Mexico. If the Burmuda high extends even further west, tropical storms can move west right across the Gulf of Mexico and hit Texas or Mexico. A figure showing the number of Atlantic landfalling US hurricanes from 1900 - 2007 by county has been produced by the National Hurricane Center.

Once hurricanes move north of 30° latitude, they generally pick up speed (because the steering winds generally become stronger away from the tropics) and will eventually turn toward the east (because prevailing 500 mb winds in the middle latitudes are more likely to be from west to east). When tropical storms move into the middle latitudes, it is common for them to get "picked up" by the winds associated with a 500 mb longwave trough and move toward the north and east. The areas of the United States at risk from Atlantic hurricanes includes the entire Gulf of Mexico coastline and the entire eastern seaboard, which includes the larger northeastern cities like New York. This was made obviously clear with Hurricane Sandy, which devastated parts of the large metropolitan areas of the northeastern United States. While it is much less likely that a major hurricane will hit New York City compared with areas further south, it has happened in the past History Reveals Hurricane Threat to New York City. Note that the article was written in 2005 before hurricane Sandy. The "Great Hurricane of 1938" slammed into Long Island and devistated much of southern New England as a category 3 storm. The last direct hit on New York City was back in 1821. Because much of the New York metro area is just above sea level, the city quite vulnerable to a strong hit. To make matters worse, the only way a really strong hurricane is going to hit New York City is if it turns north and moves very quickly, so that it does not have time to weaken much as it moves over colder water, potentially leaving little time for evacuations.

The Effects of Pacific Hurricanes on the Continental United States

Although the west coast of the United States has never been hit by a hurricane, it is not all that uncommon for the west coast and desert southwest to get heavy rain events from remnants of eastern Pacific tropical storms and hurricanes (see California's Tropical Storms). As shown in figure 3 above, most eastern Pacific hurricanes move westward out into the Pacific ocean away from the North American continent. However, if a storm gets "picked up" by the winds associated with a middle latitude 500 mb trough, it can be turned north and east back toward North America. This is most likely to happen late in the hurricane season (mid-September and later) because as the seasons change, there is enough cold air that troughs can begin to dig into southern parts of the US. Recently, in October 2014, Tucson received well over one inch of rain from the remnants of Hurricane Simon. As these storms move northward, they encounter the colder waters of the eastern Pacific and weaken below hurricane strength before reaching the United States. Basically, it is the cold sea surface temperatures along the southwest Pacific coast that prevent hurricanes from reaching the western United States. Further south along Baja California and the Mexican Pacific coast, the water can be warm enough to support hurricanes, and these areas do experience hurricanes from time to time. The following link shows the Current sea surface temperatures across the tropics as well as any active tropical weather systems. Notice the relatively cool water temperature in the Pacific Ocean off the US west coast and Baja California, Mexico. This water is much colder than the Atlantic Ocean water in the Gulf of Mexico and off the southeastern coast of the US. If there are any active tropical storms this time of year, they will most likely be in the Southern Hemisphere, since it is summer there and winter here in the northern hemisphere.

Predicting Hurricane Movement and Intensity, Giving Public Warnings

The text above summarizes the typical paths taken by hurricanes. However, as many of you know the actual path taken by a hurricane can be caotic and difficult to predict. One difficulty lies in the fact that the upper level winds that can steer hurricanes (pressure levels at 500 mb and higher altitudes) are often quite weak in the tropics. When steering winds are weak, the actual path of a hurricane is determined by the structure of the storm and the storm's interaction with the environment. Factors that may contribute to a storms path include: a nearby area of ever so slightly warmer or colder sea temperatures, interactions between the storm and nearby land areas, the relative location and intensity of convection within a storm, or weak and unnoticed disturbances in the upper air wind flow. Thus, it is not all that uncommon for hurricanes to take erratic paths and make odd turns that catch weather forecasters by surprise. If you are interested, you can look at the track of all Atlantic Hurricanes from 1851-2013 (from Unisys)

The National Hurrican Center in Miami, Florida uses sophisticated computer models to predict hurricane movement. Forecasters use these models to predict both the hurricane track, i.e., the future position of the storm center, and the hurricane's intensity, i.e., will it stengthen or weaken in the future. Although there are still many aspects of hurricane evolution that we do not understand, steady progress has been made in improving forecasts of hurricane movement or future position (see Figure 6).

A more challenging problem is to predict the future intensity of hurricanes, that is will they strengthen or weaken and how fast will these changes occur. The problem here is caused by both by our lack of understanding of hurricane evolution, which results in poor forecasts by computer models, as well as the lack of observations or measurements near the storm's center, which are necessary to understand exactly what is happening. The big problem is pointed out by Max Mayfield, director of the National Hurricane Center -- "Most major hurricanes become major hurricanes by going through some rapid intensification cycle that we just don't understand ..." This sets up the possibility of what Mayfield calls his "nightmare scenario" -- where for example, a rather weak hurricane just off the coast rapidly intensifies to a major hurricane overnight, and slams into a coastal region where the population is unprepared. "We still haven't had that nightmare scenario where people go to bed prepared for a Category 1 hurricane and wake up to a Category 4," Mayfield says. "That's going to happen one of these days, and it's going to be devastating."

Figure 6: Official Track Errors for Atlantic Ocean Tropical Storms and Hurricanes by decade (source NHC) (n mi = nautical miles, where 1 n mi = 1.15 mi)

Figure 7. Example showing area over which hurricane warnings are issued (source NHC).

With modern techniques of forecasting and tracking hurricane paths, it is always possible to issue warnings about the "probable" locations that will be affected by any given hurricane. Although hurricanes can be easily tracked using satellite data, predictions of their future movement and intensity are by no means certain. Based on the estimated uncertainty in future hurricane movement, hurricane watches and warnings are issued for a wide swath as shown in Figure 7. Notice in the example that the hurricane warning area is three times larger than the extent of the hurricane winds shown in green. This means that many areas under the warning will not receive hurricane force winds. The reason for the larger warning area is to account for the known uncertainty in the predicted path of hurricanes. This is a "better safe than sorry" approach and probably the best way to warn the public of possible hurricane landfall. The problem with this approach is there will be places that will under a hurricane warning that will not encounter hurricane force winds. People living in these areas may could be more prone to ignore future hurricane warnings or consider them untrustworthy. The National Hurricane Center defines hurricane watches and warnings as follows:

• Hurricane Watch: An announcement of specific coastal areas that a hurricane or an incipient hurricane condition (sustained winds > 74 mph) poses a possible threat, generally within 36 hours.
• Hurricane Warning: A warning that sustained winds of 74 mph or higher associated with a hurricane are expected in a specified coastal area in 24 hours or less. A hurricane warning can remain in effect when dangerously high water or a combination of dangerously high water and exceptionally high waves continue, even though winds may be less than hurricane force.

Current Hurricane Activity

Map showing the current global sea surface temperatures and location of tropical systems (from Weather Underground Hurricanes).

The figure on above shows the positions of all active tropical systems on Earth as well as current sea surface temperatures. Recall that the surface water temperature needs to be at least 80°F (26.5°C) for tropical storm formation and strengthening. These regions are shaded in red in the image above. This is the warm time of year for southern hemisphere oceans and the cooler time of the year for northern hemisphere oceans. Click on the link in the figure caption to open an interactive map of the figure below. You can click on individual storms to see the storm history and forecasts of future storm position and intensity. You can also vist the US National Hurricane Center for a look at current tropical systems in the Atlantic and Eastern Pacific Ocean basins.

Destruction at Landfall

Although we usually categorize hurricanes in terms of their windspeed (see Safir-Simpson table below), coastal flooding due to what is called the storm surge usually causes the most damage. A storm surge is an abnormally high rise in sea level along a shoreline caused primarily by high winds pushing and piling up water. It can be rather misleading to think of the storm surge as big waves. The storm surge is a large dome of water that can be over 100 km in width, which sweeps over the coastline. Storm surges have demolished marinas, piers, boardwalks, houses, and other shoreline structures, while eroding beaches and washing out coastal roads and railroads. The height of the dome of water depends on the windspeed as shown in the Saffir-Simpson table below. With a hurricane (in the Northern Hemisphere), the most damaging storm surge and strongest winds occur to the right of the storm's center. The right side of the storm is where the wind blows directly onshore and where the windspeed is highest for a moving storm (See Figure O, storm surge diagram showing why the most damage is expected just to the right of the eye). You are expected to understand the reason why the greatest potential damage from landfalling Northern Hemisphere hurricanes happens in the region just to the right side of the where eye makes landfall, as described in Figure O.

The damage potential associated with a storm surge depends upon many factors. Some of the most important factors include:

1. The strength of the wind and the areal extent of the strong winds, i.e., large storms produce stronger surges than small storms. The size of the storm is important because the longer the "fetch" or the path length of strong winds over the ocean, the more water that can be piled up.
2. The timing of the surge with relationship to the normal high and low tides. The storm surge adds on top of the normal tides. Thus, the worst situation would be for the storm to hit at high tide because the water level is already high and the storm surge adds on top of that. If the storm hits at low tide (normal high tide adds to the height of the storm surge).
3. The shape of the coastline, i.e., the slope of the Earth's solid surface near the coastline. In other words, if you were to walk out into the ocean, how rapidly does the water depth increase. The more gradual the slope, the higher the damage potential because the same height storm surge will move further inland. See figures below.

Gradually sloped shoreline

Steeply sloped shoreline

Forecasting the strength and severity of a storm surge that will happen as a hurricane makes landfall is complicated. Forecasters must rely on computer models. The models need to accurately account for the shape and slope of the coastline in relationship to the wind direction. Accurately predicting the storm surge near inlets, bays, and river outlets is quite challenging as described in this article on storm surge prediction from NOAA. You are not expected to study the article as part of this course. Read depending upon your interest.

In addition to the storm surge, the strong winds generated by hurricanes can cause considerable damage. Hurricane strength winds can damage or destroy vehicles, buildings, bridges, etc. High winds also turn loose debris into flying projectiles, making the outdoor environment even more dangerous. As hurricanes come in many sizes, the area covered by hurricane force winds is a factor in the total amount of damage done. For example, not only was Katrina a very powerful storm, it was also a very large storm.

Flooding caused by the heavy rains associated with hurricanes is another concern. This can be dangerous when a slow moving or nearly stationary hurricane sits just offshore causing a prolonged period of heavy rains over nearby coastal areas. This can be especially problematic if the nearby coast has sharply rising mountains, enhancing the heavy rains by orographic lifting, with the runoff causing landslides.

Damage may also occur from hurricane-spawned tornadoes that may form as the hurricane interacts with land areas. Most hurricanes that strike the United States produce at least one tornado. About one-quarter of land-falling hurricanes produce significant numbers of tornadoes. Tornadoes are most likely to develop in the right front quadrant of the storm (in relation to the motion of the storm), and are more likely to be associated with a spiral rain band rather than the storm's center. They result from the vertical wind shear that often develops in the lower levels of the hurricane's circulation as the storm winds interact with the land. Most hurricane-spawned tornadoes are of the weak variety (compared to the monsters that can form over the great plains of the United States), but can still produce significant damage.

Hurricanes weaken rapidly after making landfall since the storm is cutoff from its fuel supply (the warm ocean water). Although winds weaken, heavy and flooding rains may move far inland with the storm remnants.

In summary, the possible dangers associated with a hurricane are:

• storm surge
• strong winds
• heavy rains (and flooding)
• associated tornadoes

Ever wonder what it would be like to be near the coast when a major hurricane strikes? Many amateur videos taken during and after hurricane Katrina can be viewed YouTube index of Hurricane Katrina vidoes. Check out the excellent Storm Surge video from Gulfport, MS and this video showing the extreme destruction that remained in Mississippi 47 days after Katrina.

Distribution of Major Landfalling hurricanes in the United States

Map indicating the location and strength of all major landfalling hurricanes (category 3 and higher) in the United States from 1899 through 2008. The overall average is slightly less than one per year. 2005 had a record of four major landfalling hurricanes: Dennis, Katrina, Rita, and Wilma.